+91 75880 82870
Rajyaseva Setu
← All fundamentals

History · Themes in Indian History, Part I · Theme 4

Thinkers, Beliefs and Buildings — Cultural Developments (c. 600 BCE–600 CE)

Centred on the stupa at Sanchi, this theme covers a thousand years of philosophical ferment (Upanishads, Ajivikas, Lokayatas, Jainism, Buddhism), how the Buddha's teachings and the sangha were organised, how stupas and sculpture were built and later 'discovered' by colonial-era scholars, and the rise of Mahayana Buddhism and Puranic Hinduism alongside early temple architecture.

Sanchi — a monument's own story

  • Sanchi (Madhya Pradesh) has one of the best-preserved stupa complexes, including a fifth-century temple, crowning a hill. The rulers of Bhopal — Shahjehan Begum and her successor Sultan Jehan Begum — funded its preservation, the museum and guesthouse where John Marshall lived and wrote his volumes on Sanchi, which he dedicated to Sultan Jehan.
  • The French sought Shahjehan Begum's permission to take Sanchi's best-preserved eastern gateway to a French museum; the English wanted this too. Both were eventually satisfied with plaster-cast copies, and the original stayed at the site — a rare survival compared with sites looted for European museums.

The background — sacrifice and new questions

  • The mid-first-millennium BCE is a world-historical turning point: Zarathustra in Iran, Kong Zi (Confucius) in China, Socrates/Plato/Aristotle in Greece, and Mahavira and the Buddha in India — all grappling with the mysteries of existence, alongside new kingdoms/cities and changing Ganga-valley social-economic life.
  • The Rigveda (compiled c. 1500-1000 BCE) praised deities like Agni, Indra and Soma through hymns chanted at sacrifices where people prayed for cattle, sons, health, long life. Sacrifices were first collective; from c. 1000-500 BCE, householders performed some for domestic well-being, while elaborate ones (rajasuya, ashvamedha) were performed by chiefs/kings through Brahmana priests.
  • The Upanishads (c. 6th century BCE onwards) show people questioning the meaning of life, life after death, and whether rebirth depended on past actions (karma) — and, from outside the Vedic tradition, whether a single ultimate reality even existed. Buddhist texts mention as many as 64 rival sects/schools of thought; teachers debated in a kutagarashala (pointed-roof hut) or groves, and a philosopher who won a debate gained his rival's followers as disciples too, so a sect's support could rise or fall over time.
  • Many teachers, including Mahavira and the Buddha, questioned Vedic authority and stressed individual agency — men and women could strive for liberation themselves — in sharp contrast to the Brahmanical view that existence was determined by birth in a caste/gender. The Ajivikas (fatalists — everything predetermined, pleasure/pain fixed like an unwinding ball of string, taught by Makkhali Gosala) and the Lokayatas (materialists — a person is just four elements returning to earth/water/fire/air at death, no world beyond, taught by Ajita Kesakambalin) are known only through rival texts, since their own have not survived.

Jainism

  • Jaina philosophy predates Vardhamana Mahavira (6th century BCE); tradition holds he was preceded by 23 other tirthankaras ('those who guide across the river of existence'). Its central idea: the entire world is animated — even stones, rocks and water have life — so non-injury (ahimsa) to living beings, especially humans, animals, plants and insects, is central, and has left its mark on Indian thought as a whole.
  • The cycle of birth/rebirth is shaped by karma; asceticism and penance free one from it, and this requires renouncing the world, so monastic life is essential for salvation. Jaina monks and nuns took five vows: abstain from killing, stealing and lying; observe celibacy; abstain from possessing property. Mahavira's teachings, like the Buddha's, were preserved by disciples, often as stories for ordinary people — e.g. the Prakrit Uttaradhyayana Sutta's tale of Queen Kamalavati persuading her husband to renounce the world, since only dhamma, not treasure, will save him when he dies.
  • Jainism gradually spread across India; Jaina scholars produced literature in Prakrit, Sanskrit and Tamil, preserved for centuries in temple libraries. Some of the earliest stone sculptures linked to any religious tradition were made by devotees of the Jaina tirthankaras.

The Buddha and his teachings

  • Siddhartha, son of a Sakya chief, had a sheltered upbringing until a journey outside the palace showed him an old man, a sick man and a corpse — revealing that bodily decay is inevitable — and a homeless mendicant at peace with old age, disease and death. He left the palace, tried and abandoned extreme bodily mortification, meditated for days, attained enlightenment and became 'the Buddha' (the Enlightened One), thereafter teaching dhamma, the path of righteous living. (Historians reconstruct his life partly from hagiographies — biographies of a saint/religious leader, often not literally accurate but revealing of followers' beliefs.)
  • Core philosophy: the world is transient (anicca) and constantly changing; it is soulless (anatta), nothing permanent/eternal exists; sorrow (dukkha) is intrinsic to existence within this transient world. Following a middle path — moderation between severe penance and self-indulgence — lets people rise above worldly troubles. In earliest Buddhism, whether god existed was irrelevant; the Buddha saw the social world as a human, not divine, creation, and advised kings and gahapatis (householders) to be humane and ethical, expecting individual effort to transform social relations. His reported last words: 'Be lamps unto yourselves as all of you must work out your own liberation.'
  • Teaching method: reconstructed mainly from the Sutta Pitaka's stories, narrated in the language of ordinary people for easy understanding. Some stories show miraculous powers, but others show the Buddha persuading through reason — e.g. gently convincing a grief-stricken mother of the inevitability of death rather than reviving her dead child. His advice to the wealthy householder Sigala (Sutta Pitaka) covered practical ethics: masters should assign servants work suited to their strength, supply food/wages, tend them in sickness, share delicacies, and grant leave; clansmen should support samanas (renouncers) and Brahmanas with open houses and affection.

The sangha and its followers

  • The Buddha founded the sangha, an organisation of monks (also later nuns) who became teachers of dhamma themselves, living simply on alms (hence 'bhikkhus') with only essential possessions like a food bowl. Women were admitted later, through the mediation of the disciple Ananda; the Buddha's foster mother Mahapajapati Gotami was the first woman ordained as a bhikkhuni, and many women who joined became theris (respected, liberated women teachers) — their spiritual verses form the Therigatha, part of the Sutta Pitaka. The Therigatha's verses by Punna, a dasi (slave woman) water-carrier, mock a Brahmana's belief that bathing in the river washes away evil — 'all the frogs and turtles... would go to heaven' — showing how sangha membership let even a slave woman publicly challenge Brahmanical ritual.
  • Followers spanned kings, wealthy men, gahapatis, and humbler folk — workers, slaves, craftspeople; inside the sangha all shed their earlier social identity and were treated as equal. Internal functioning followed the older gana/sangha tradition of consensus through discussion, falling back on a vote if needed.
  • The Vinaya Pitaka's detailed monastic rules (e.g. a new felt blanket had to be kept at least six years before replacing it; alms of cakes/grain-meal beyond two-three bowlfuls had to be shared with other bhikkhus; bedding had to be put away or leave taken before departing) show how communal monastic life was regulated in practice.

Preserving Buddhist texts

  • The Buddha taught orally through discussion and debate; none of his speeches were written down in his lifetime. After his death (c. 5th-4th century BCE) his teachings were compiled by disciples at a council of elders/senior monks at Vesali (Vaishali), first oral, then written and classified as the Tipitaka ('three baskets'): the Vinaya Pitaka (monastic rules), Sutta Pitaka (the Buddha's teachings) and Abhidhamma Pitaka (philosophy). Some of the oldest texts are in Pali, later ones in Sanskrit.
  • As Buddhism spread to Sri Lanka, regional-history texts like the Dipavamsa and Mahavamsa were written, containing Buddha biographies. Chinese pilgrims Fa Xian and Xuan Zang travelled to India in search of texts to take home for translation; Indian Buddhist teachers carried texts abroad too. Manuscripts survived for centuries in monasteries across Asia; modern translations draw on Pali, Sanskrit, Chinese and Tibetan versions.

Stupas — why and how they were built

  • As the dying Buddha lay down, Ananda asked what to do with his remains; the Buddha initially deflected the question ('hinder not yourselves... be intent on your own good'), but when pressed, said a thupa (stupa) should be built at the four crossroads, and that reverence shown there would bring profit and joy — the canonical justification for stupa-building (Mahaparinibbana Sutta).
  • Stupas were mounds containing relics — the Buddha's bodily remains or objects he used — regarded as sacred, so the entire stupa was venerated as an emblem of both the Buddha and Buddhism (the tradition of mound-building may itself be pre-Buddhist). The Ashokavadana says Asoka distributed portions of the Buddha's relics to every important town and ordered stupas built over them; by the 2nd century BCE, stupas at Bharhut, Sanchi and Sarnath existed. Places tied to the Buddha's life — Lumbini (birth), Bodh Gaya (enlightenment), Sarnath (first sermon), Kusinagara (death/mahaparinibbana) — became sacred sites in their own right; Asoka erected a pillar at Lumbini to mark his visit there.
  • Inscriptions on railings/pillars record who funded construction: kings such as the Satavahanas; guilds, such as the ivory workers who financed part of a Sanchi gateway; and hundreds of ordinary women and men (donors sometimes named their hometown, occupation and relatives), plus bhikkhus and bhikkhunis themselves.
  • Structure: the stupa (Sanskrit for 'heap') began as a simple semi-circular earth mound, later called the anda; above it, the harmika, a balcony-like structure representing the abode of the gods; rising from the harmika, a mast (yashti), often topped by a chhatri (umbrella); a railing around the mound separated sacred from secular space. Early stupas at Sanchi/Bharhut had plain mounds but richly carved gateways at the four cardinal points; worshippers entered through the eastern gateway and circled clockwise, imitating the sun's path. Later stupas (Amaravati, Shahji-ki-Dheri in Peshawar) had elaborately carved mounds too.

Discovering and preserving stupas — Amaravati vs Sanchi

  • In 1796 a local raja wanting to build a temple stumbled on the Amaravati stupa's ruins and used its stone, hoping for buried treasure. Colin Mackenzie visited later and made drawings, never published. In 1854 Walter Elliot, Commissioner of Guntur, collected sculpture panels (the 'Elliot marbles') and took them to Madras, concluding Amaravati was one of the largest, most magnificent stupas ever built. By the 1850s slabs had been dispersed to the Asiatic Society of Bengal (Calcutta), the India Office (Madras), London, and even British administrators' gardens — new officials kept removing pieces on the grounds that earlier ones had done so too.
  • Archaeologist H.H. Cole opposed this ('a suicidal and indefensible policy to allow the country to be looted of original works of ancient art'), arguing museums should keep plaster-cast facsimiles while originals stayed in situ (on the spot). He failed to save Amaravati but succeeded for Sanchi. When Sanchi was 'discovered' in 1818, three of its four gateways still stood and the mound was in good condition; even so, one gateway was nearly shipped to Paris or London. A combination of factors kept Sanchi intact, while the Amaravati mahachaitya survives today only as an insignificant mound, stripped of its former glory — a contrast the textbook uses to show how the timing of 'discovery' (before or after scholars grasped the value of leaving finds in situ) shaped a site's fate.

Reading the sculpture

  • Stories in stone: at first glance, a Sanchi panel showing thatched huts/trees looks like a rural scene, but art historians identify it as the Vessantara Jataka — a generous prince who gave away everything and lived in the forest with his family — matched to the sculpture only by comparing it against textual evidence.
  • Symbols of worship: early sculptors did not show the Buddha in human form — an empty seat indicated his meditation, a stupa represented the mahaparinibbana, and a wheel stood for his first sermon at Sarnath. Understanding these required art historians to become familiar with hagiographic traditions, since such images cannot be read literally.
  • Popular traditions blended in: the shalabhanjika motif (a woman whose touch made trees flower/fruit, by popular Sanskrit belief) appears at Sanchi gateways despite having nothing to do with renunciation, showing that Buddhism absorbed pre-Buddhist and non-Buddhist beliefs. Animals (elephants, horses, monkeys, cattle) were both drawn from Jataka stories and used as symbols of human traits — e.g. elephants for strength and wisdom. Serpent motifs on pillars led an early scholar, James Fergusson — unfamiliar with (still-untranslated) Buddhist literature — to wrongly conclude Sanchi was a centre of tree/serpent worship, purely from studying the images alone.
  • Ajanta's paintings (Maharashtra) — the best-preserved of their kind — depict Jataka stories, courtly life, processions, work and festivals, using shading for a three-dimensional effect. A recurring figure of a woman with lotuses/elephants performing what looks like an abhisheka (consecration) is read by some historians as Maya, the Buddha's mother, and by others as the popular goddess Gajalakshmi — possibly both meanings coexisted for different viewers.

Mahayana Buddhism and Puranic Hinduism

  • By the 1st century CE, Buddhist ideas shifted: early teachings stressed self-effort toward nibbana and saw the Buddha as a human who attained enlightenment by his own efforts, but gradually the idea of a saviour emerged, alongside the Bodhisatta concept — compassionate beings who earned merit but used it to help others rather than exit the world. Worshipping images of the Buddha and Bodhisattas became central to this new approach, called Mahayana ('the great vehicle'); its followers labelled the older tradition Hinayana ('the lesser vehicle'), though its own adherents called themselves Theravadins ('those who follow the path of the theras/elders').
  • A similar 'saviour' idea grew within what we now call Hinduism: Vaishnavism (Vishnu as principal deity) and Shaivism (Shiva as chief god) increasingly emphasised bhakti — a bond of love/devotion between worshipper and a chosen deity. Vaishnavism recognised ten avatars, forms the deity assumed to save the world from evil/disorder; different avatars were likely popular in different regions, and treating each as a form of Vishnu helped unify the tradition. Shiva was often symbolised by the linga, occasionally shown in human form.
  • The Puranas (compiled by Brahmanas by roughly the mid-first millennium CE) held centuries-old stories about gods/goddesses, written in simple Sanskrit verse meant to be read aloud to everyone, including women and Shudras excluded from Vedic learning — and much of their content evolved through interaction among priests, merchants and ordinary travellers exchanging ideas. Vasudeva-Krishna, originally an important deity around Mathura, spread across the country this way over centuries.

Temple architecture

  • Around the time stupas like Sanchi's reached their present form, the first temples housing images of gods/goddesses were being built. The early temple was a small square room, the garbhagriha ('womb-house'), with a single doorway; over time a tall shikhara (spire) rose above the central shrine, walls were decorated with sculpture, and later temples added assembly halls, boundary walls, gateways and water-supply arrangements.
  • A unique strand: temples hollowed out of solid rock as artificial caves — a tradition going back to caves built on Asoka's orders (3rd century BCE) for Ajivika renouncers at Barabar (Bihar), culminating centuries later (8th century CE) in the entire Kailashnatha temple at Ellora (Maharashtra) carved from a single rock — its chief sculptor's copperplate inscription records his own astonishment: 'Oh how did I make it!'

Can we "see" everything? — the limits of interpretation

  • Nineteenth-century European scholars, confronted with unfamiliar multi-armed/multi-headed or part-animal sculptures, made sense of them by comparing them to Greek sculpture they already knew — a case of 'devising yardsticks derived from the familiar to make sense of the unfamiliar.' Images of the Buddha/Bodhisattas clearly modelled on Greek statues (mostly from north-western cities like Taxila and Peshawar, where Indo-Greek rulers had established kingdoms from the 2nd century BCE) were therefore rated as the 'best' early Indian art by these scholars — a judgement shaped by their own familiarity, not necessarily by the art's actual significance to its original makers/viewers.
  • Even matching text to image is not always conclusive: a famous rock-cut panel at Mahabalipuram (Tamil Nadu) divides art historians — some read it as the Ganga's descent from heaven (the rock's natural cleft representing the river, a story told in the Puranas/epics), others as Arjuna's penance on a riverbank to obtain weapons (a Mahabharata episode), pointing to the panel's central ascetic figure. And finally, most rituals/beliefs/practices of the past were never recorded in any permanent visible form at all — what survives as monuments, sculpture and painting is, in the textbook's own words, 'just the tip of the iceberg.'

Key terms

Ajivikas / Lokayatas
Fatalist and materialist schools known only through rival (Buddhist) texts, since their own did not survive.
Ahimsa
Non-injury to living beings, central to Jaina philosophy.
Anicca / anatta / dukkha
Buddhist core ideas: the world is transient / soulless; sorrow is intrinsic to existence.
Sangha / bhikkhu / theri
The monastic order / a monk living on alms / a respected, liberated woman teacher.
Stupa — anda / harmika / yashti
The mound / the balcony-like abode of the gods above it / the mast rising from it, often topped by an umbrella.
Mahayana / Theravada
The 'great vehicle' (saviour Buddha, Bodhisattas, image worship) vs. the older tradition, self-named Theravada.
Garbhagriha / shikhara
The inner sanctum housing the deity's image / the tower rising above it.

Quick revision

  • 1.Sanchi survived largely intact (Cole's in-situ policy worked); Amaravati was stripped and scattered to museums.
  • 2.Tipitaka = Vinaya (rules) + Sutta (teachings) + Abhidhamma (philosophy).
  • 3.Buddha's life sites: Lumbini (birth), Bodh Gaya (enlightenment), Sarnath (first sermon), Kusinagara (death).
  • 4.Mahayana added: saviour Buddha, Bodhisattas, image worship — parallels Vaishnavism/Shaivism's bhakti and avatars.
  • 5.Barabar caves (Asoka, Ajivikas) → Kailashnatha, Ellora (8th century, single-rock temple).

Practice questions

Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.

  1. 1.How do historians use Buddhist literature to interpret the sculpture at Sanchi? Give at least two examples.
  2. 2.Why did Sanchi survive relatively intact while Amaravati did not? What role did the Begums of Bhopal play?
  3. 3.Discuss the rise of Mahayana Buddhism and its parallels with the growth of bhakti in Vaishnavism and Shaivism.

These are original study notes prepared from the NCERT Class XII textbook for exam preparation, not a reproduction of it. For the full text, maps and illustrations, read the original textbook on the official NCERT website (ncert.nic.in).