+91 75880 82870
Rajyaseva Setu
← All fundamentals

History · Themes in Indian History, Part I · Theme 3

Kinship, Caste and Class — Early Societies (c. 600 BCE–600 CE)

This theme uses the Mahabharata — and the Critical Edition project that reconstructed it — to explore how historians read texts for social history: kinship and patriliny, marriage rules, the varna/caste order and its limits, and how access to resources shaped status by gender and class.

The Critical Edition of the Mahabharata

  • From 1919, a team led by Sanskritist V.S. Sukthankar collected Mahabharata manuscripts from across the subcontinent (Kashmir/Nepal to Kerala/Tamil Nadu), compared verses across versions, and published the common verses — over 13,000 pages, taking 47 years. More than half those pages record regional variations in footnotes/appendices, reflecting dialogue between dominant traditions and resilient local practices.
  • Early (19th-20th century) historians took normative Sanskrit texts at face value, assuming prescriptions were actually practised. Later study of Pali, Prakrit and Tamil sources showed Brahmanical norms were recognised as authoritative but also questioned, and sometimes rejected.
  • The Mahabharata (over 100,000 verses, composed over ~1,000 years from c. 500 BCE) tells of a feud between two sets of cousins, and mixes narrative with didactic (instructional) sections on social norms — historians treat this division as a guide, not a rigid boundary.

Kinship and marriage

  • Sanskrit terms: kula (family), jnati (wider kinfolk network), vamsha (lineage). Patriliny traces descent father→son→grandson; matriliny traces it through the mother.
  • The Mahabharata's central feud (Kauravas vs Pandavas, of the Kuru lineage) ends with patrilineal succession proclaimed — reinforcing an ideal that already existed. Under patriliny sons claimed a father's resources/throne; most dynasties from c. 6th century BCE claimed to follow this, though practice varied (brothers succeeding, other kinsmen claiming the throne, and — very exceptionally — women like Prabhavati Gupta wielding power). A Rigvedic marriage mantra (c. 1000 BCE, still used today) prays for a bride to have 'fine sons,' showing the concern with patriliny extended beyond ruling families.
  • Daughters had no claim on household resources; marrying them outside the kin (exogamy) was considered ideal, giving rise to kanyadana (gift of a daughter) as a father's religious duty. As towns grew and social life became more complex, Brahmanas from c. 500 BCE compiled detailed behavioural codes — the Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras — the most important being the Manusmriti (c. 200 BCE–200 CE). These texts recognised eight forms of marriage; only the first four were 'approved,' suggesting the rest were real practices outside Brahmanical norms.
  • Endogamy (marriage within a kin/caste/locality unit) versus exogamy (marriage outside it); polygyny (one man, several wives) versus polyandry (one woman, several husbands). Gotra (from c. 1000 BCE) classified people — especially Brahmanas — as descendants of a named Vedic seer; women were expected to adopt their husband's gotra, and same-gotra marriage was forbidden. Satavahana inscriptions (western India/Deccan, c. 2nd century BCE–2nd century CE) show rulers named by metronymics (e.g. Gotami-puta, 'son of Gotami'), but several royal wives kept their father's gotra name and some married within the same gotra — endogamy, a south Indian pattern that contradicted the Brahmanical exogamy ideal.

Varna, jati and the caste order

  • The Dharmasutras/Dharmashastras laid out an ideal hierarchical order (caste) with Brahmanas ranked first and Shudras/'untouchables' at the bottom, claimed to be divinely ordained and birth-determined. Prescribed occupations: Brahmanas study/teach the Vedas, perform and get sacrifices done, give/receive gifts; Kshatriyas fight, protect, administer justice, plus the Brahmana duties; Vaishyas share those three plus agriculture/pastoralism/trade; Shudras had only one 'occupation' — serving the other three varnas.
  • Enforcement strategies: claiming divine origin (the Purusha sukta hymn in the Rigveda describes the four varnas emanating from the body of the primeval man Purusha — Brahmana from the mouth, Kshatriya from the arms, Vaishya from the thighs, Shudra from the feet); advising kings to enforce the norms; and reinforcing prescriptions through stories. The Ekalavya story (Drona refuses to teach a nishada/forest-hunter archery; Ekalavya trains himself, then is forced by Drona to cut off his thumb as 'fee' so no one surpasses the Kshatriya Arjuna) illustrates how such stories policed 'proper' social roles.
  • Reality was messier: only Kshatriyas could supposedly be kings, but the Mauryas' origins are debated (Buddhist texts call them Kshatriyas, Brahmanical texts call them 'low' origin); the Shungas/Kanvas who followed them were Brahmanas; political power really went to whoever could muster support and resources. 'Barbarian' Shaka rulers like Rudradaman (c. 2nd century CE) used Sanskrit and rebuilt Sudarshana lake. The Satavahana king Gotami-puta Siri-Satakani claimed to be a unique Brahmana who stopped inter-varna marriage — yet married into Rudradaman's Shaka family and practised endogamy, not the prescribed exogamy.
  • Jati, unlike the fixed four varnas, had no numerical limit — Brahmanical authorities classified any new group (forest-dwellers like nishadas) or occupational category (goldsmith/suvarnakara) that didn't fit the varna system as a jati. Jatis sharing an occupation sometimes organised into shrenis (guilds). A c. 5th-century CE Mandasor (Madhya Pradesh) inscription records a silk-weavers' guild that migrated from Gujarat, whose members pooled craft earnings to build a sun temple — while individually pursuing varied occupations (music, storytelling, religious discourse, astronomy, even warfare), showing jati membership didn't mean occupational uniformity. Some, like the merchant (vanik) hero of the play Mrichchhakatika, were described as both Brahmana and merchant, blurring the neat varna-occupation link entirely.

Beyond the varna framework

  • Forest-dwellers (hunter-gatherers like the nishadas) and nomadic pastoralists sat outside the settled-agriculturist framework and were often described in Sanskrit texts as odd or animal-like; non-Sanskritic speakers were labelled mlechchhas. Yet ideas were shared across these boundaries, as Mahabharata stories like Bhima's marriage to the rakshasa woman Hidimba suggest (some historians read 'rakshasa' as a label for people following non-Brahmanical practices).
  • A sharper divide separated 'untouchables' (chandalas), associated with 'polluting' work like handling corpses/dead animals. The Manusmriti confined chandalas to living outside villages, using discarded utensils, wearing the dead's clothes and iron ornaments, and barred them from towns at night; they had to bury unclaimed bodies and serve as executioners. Chinese pilgrims Fa Xian (c. 5th century CE) and Xuan Zang (c. 7th century) noted 'untouchables' had to sound a clapper to warn others, and executioners/scavengers lived outside cities. Non-Brahmanical texts sometimes confirm this and sometimes suggest a different reality — the Matanga Jataka (Pali) tells of the Bodhisattva born as a chandala, humiliated by a merchant's daughter, who later challenges the idea that birth (rather than freedom from vice) determines worth.

Resources, gender and class

  • The dice game in the Mahabharata — where Yudhisthira stakes and loses his wealth, kingdom, brothers, himself, and finally Draupadi — dramatises the era's property rules. The Manusmriti divided a father's estate equally among sons (eldest getting an extra share); daughters had no claim. Women kept marriage gifts as stridhana (inheritable by their children, husband had no claim), but Manusmriti still warned women against hoarding property or valuables without their husband's permission. Manusmriti lists seven ways men could acquire wealth (inheritance, finding, purchase, conquest, investment, work, gifts) against six for women (mostly forms of gifts, from fire/marriage, bridal procession, or affectionate relatives/husband) — despite elite women like Prabhavati Gupta holding resources, land/cattle/money were generally male-controlled.
  • Varna also gated wealth in theory (only the first three varnas had prescribed 'occupations,' Shudras only servitude) — and kings/priests are indeed usually shown as wealthy in texts. Early Buddhism (c. 6th century BCE onwards) challenged this: the Majjhima Nikaya's dialogue on 'the wealthy Shudra' has the Buddhist Kachchana get a king to concede that a rich Shudra could command obedience from a Brahmana or Kshatriya just as easily — so varna made no practical difference. In ancient Tamilakam, Sangam poems (c. 1st century CE) instead prized generosity: chiefs were expected to share wealth with bards, and stinginess was despised.
  • A Buddhist social-contract myth (Sutta Pitaka) offers a different explanation for inequality and kingship altogether: humans, originally peaceful, grew greedy and deceitful, so they collectively chose a person (mahasammata, 'the great elect') to punish wrongdoing in exchange for a share of the rice crop — kingship and taxation as a human choice/institution, not a divine order, implying it could also be changed.

How historians handle the text itself

  • Historians weigh: the language (Sanskrit for elites/priests versus Prakrit/Pali/Tamil closer to ordinary people); the kind of text (ritual mantra versus retold story); the author(s) and intended audience; and probable date/place — only then do they use content to assess historical significance. The Mahabharata is called an itihasa ('thus it was'), but whether it preserves a real war is debated — some see a kernel of real kin conflict, others find no corroborating evidence.
  • Composition traced across centuries: originally oral poems by charioteer-bards (sutas) praising Kshatriya warriors; from c. 5th century BCE Brahmanas began writing it down, as Kuru/Panchala chiefdoms became kingdoms; c. 200 BCE–200 CE saw growing Krishna-Vishnu identification; c. 200-400 CE added large didactic sections resembling the Manusmriti, swelling the text from perhaps under 10,000 verses to about 100,000 — traditionally attributed to the sage Vyasa.
  • B.B. Lal's 1951-52 excavation at Hastinapura (Meerut, UP) found mud/mud-brick houses (phase 2, c. 12th-7th century BCE) and burnt-brick houses with drains (phase 3, c. 6th-3rd century BCE) — suggestive but not proof that this was the epic's capital. Draupadi's polyandrous marriage to all five Pandavas gets three separate mythic justifications in the text itself, which historians read as a sign that polyandry (real in parts of the Himalayan region, or perhaps linked to wartime scarcity of women) grew increasingly uncomfortable for later Brahmanical redactors.
  • The epic remained dynamic — retold across languages and regions, depicted in sculpture/painting, and reworked by later writers. Bengali writer Mahashweta Devi's short story 'Kunti O Nishadi' takes up where the epic is silent: it imagines a forest encounter years later between Kunti and the daughter-in-law of the nishada woman Kunti let burn to death (along with her five sons) so the Pandavas could fake their own deaths and escape Duryodhana's plot — confronting Kunti with the six lives she never mourned.

Key terms

Patriliny / matriliny
Tracing descent through the father / through the mother.
Endogamy / exogamy
Marriage within a kin/caste/local unit / marriage outside that unit.
Gotra
A lineage named after a Vedic seer; same-gotra marriage was Brahmanically forbidden.
Varna vs. jati
Four fixed ranked categories (Brahmana/Kshatriya/Vaishya/Shudra) vs. an open-ended number of birth-based groups, often tied to occupation.
Chandala
The category placed at the very bottom of the Brahmanical order, associated with 'polluting' work.
Stridhana
A woman's own wealth (marriage gifts), inheritable by her children, outside her husband's claim.

Quick revision

  • 1.Critical Edition (1919-66): 13,000+ pages, half of it regional variations.
  • 2.8 forms of marriage in Dharmashastras; only first 4 'approved'.
  • 3.Purusha sukta: Brahmana-mouth, Kshatriya-arms, Vaishya-thighs, Shudra-feet.
  • 4.Satavahanas: claimed Brahmana status + Kshatriya-destroyer, yet married Shakas and practised endogamy.
  • 5.Buddhist social contract: kingship = human choice (mahasammata), not divine order.

Practice questions

Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.

  1. 1.How do historians use language, authorship and date to assess a text like the Mahabharata?
  2. 2.Discuss the gap between Brahmanical prescriptions on marriage and gotra, and actual practice among ruling dynasties.
  3. 3.Compare the Brahmanical (Purusha sukta) and Buddhist (social contract) explanations for social inequality.

These are original study notes prepared from the NCERT Class XII textbook for exam preparation, not a reproduction of it. For the full text, maps and illustrations, read the original textbook on the official NCERT website (ncert.nic.in).