← All fundamentals
Political Science · Democratic Politics II · Chapter 1
Power-sharing
Belgium and Sri Lanka show two contrasting ways democracies handle demands from different communities to share power — one through accommodation, the other through majoritarian imposition. This chapter draws out why power-sharing matters and the four main forms it takes in modern democracies.
Belgium: accommodation
- Belgium's ethnic composition: 59% Dutch-speaking (Flemish region), 40% French-speaking (Wallonia), 1% German-speaking; in Brussels, 80% French-speaking but only 20% Dutch-speaking, though Dutch-speakers were the national majority — creating tension, especially since the French-speaking minority was historically richer and more powerful.
- Between 1970 and 1993, Belgium amended its constitution four times to build a power-sharing model: equal numbers of Dutch and French-speaking ministers in the central government, with special laws needing majority support from each linguistic group (so no single community decides unilaterally); many central powers transferred to two State Governments (not subordinate to the centre); a separate Brussels government with equal representation for both communities; and a fourth, 'community government' elected by each language community (Dutch/French/German) regardless of where they live, handling cultural/educational/language issues.
- This complex arrangement helped avoid civic strife and a linguistic split of the country, and Brussels was chosen as the European Union's headquarters.
Sri Lanka: majoritarianism
- Sri Lanka's population: Sinhala-speakers 74% (mostly Buddhist), Tamil-speakers 18% (split between Sri Lankan Tamils, 13%, and Indian Tamils descended from colonial-era plantation workers), plus Christians of both language groups.
- After independence in 1948, Sinhala leaders used their majority to establish Sinhala supremacy: a 1956 Act made Sinhala the sole official language (disregarding Tamil); preferential policies favoured Sinhala applicants for jobs/university seats; a new constitution made the state protect and foster Buddhism. This alienated Tamils, who felt discriminated against and unheard.
- Repeated denial of demands for regional autonomy and equal opportunity led by the 1980s to demands for an independent Tamil Eelam; distrust turned into a civil war that killed thousands, displaced many as refugees, and devastated the country's social, cultural and economic life. It ended in 2009.
Why power-sharing is desirable
- Prudential reason: power-sharing reduces the possibility of conflict between social groups and ensures political stability, since imposing a majority's will may look attractive short-term but undermines national unity long-term — 'tyranny of the majority' harms even the majority in the end.
- Moral reason: power-sharing is the very spirit of democracy — a democratic rule means sharing power with those affected by its exercise; people have a right to be consulted, and a legitimate government is one where citizens gain a stake in the system through participation.
Four forms of power-sharing
- 1. Horizontal distribution — power shared among different organs of government (legislature, executive, judiciary) at the same level, each checking the others (separation of powers / checks and balances), so none can exercise unlimited power.
- 2. Vertical division — power shared among governments at different levels (general/federal government and provincial/state governments, extending down to municipality/panchayat), with the constitution clearly laying down each level's powers.
- 3. Power shared among social groups — e.g. Belgium's 'community government', or constitutional/legal arrangements like reserved constituencies that give weaker sections and women a share in government and administration.
- 4. Power shared through political parties, pressure groups and movements — competition among parties ensures power does not stay in one hand; alliances that win elections form coalition governments (direct sharing); interest groups (traders, farmers, industrial workers) influence decision-making through participation or pressure.
Key terms
- Majoritarianism
- The belief that the majority community should rule however it wants, disregarding the minority.
- Horizontal / vertical power-sharing
- Sharing among organs of government at the same level / across different levels of government.
- Prudential vs. moral reasons
- Power-sharing produces better outcomes vs. power-sharing is intrinsically valuable to democracy.
- Coalition government
- A government formed by two or more parties sharing power after winning together.
Quick revision
- 1.Belgium: accommodation via 4 constitutional amendments (1970-93) — avoided division.
- 2.Sri Lanka: 1956 Sinhala-only Act + majoritarian policies → alienation → civil war (ended 2009).
- 3.2 reasons for power-sharing: prudential (stability) and moral (democracy's spirit).
- 4.4 forms: horizontal (organs), vertical (levels of govt), social groups, political parties/pressure groups.
Practice questions
Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.
- 1.Compare how Belgium and Sri Lanka handled demands for power-sharing, and their outcomes.
- 2.Explain the prudential and moral reasons for power-sharing with an Indian example.
- 3.Describe the four forms of power-sharing found in modern democracies.
These are original study notes prepared from the NCERT Class X textbook for exam preparation, not a reproduction of it. For the full text, maps and illustrations, read the original textbook on the official NCERT website (ncert.nic.in).