Political Science · Democratic Politics II · Chapter 2
Federalism
Federalism is the vertical division of power among levels of government — one of the major forms of power-sharing. This chapter covers what makes a system federal, what makes India one, and how federalism is actually practised through linguistic states, language policy, Centre-State relations, and decentralisation to local government.
What is federalism?
- Federalism is a system of government where power is divided between a central authority and various constituent units. Usually two levels: a government for the whole country (responsible for a few subjects of common national interest) and governments at the provincial/state level (handling most day-to-day administration) — both levels enjoy power independent of the other, unlike a unitary system, where either there is only one level of government or sub-units are subordinate to and can be ordered by the centre.
- Only 25 of the world's 193 countries have federal systems, but their citizens make up 40% of the world's population — most large countries are federations. Belgium shifted from unitary to federal (1993) by giving regional governments constitutional powers independent of the centre; Sri Lanka remains, for practical purposes, unitary.
- Two routes to federation formation: (i) 'Coming together' federations — independent states pool sovereignty while retaining identity, to increase security (USA, Switzerland, Australia); constituent states usually have equal power and are strong vis-à-vis the federal government. (ii) 'Holding together' federations — a large country divides power between constituent units and the national government (India, Spain, Belgium); the Central Government tends to be more powerful, and different units often have unequal powers, some granted special status.
- Seven key features: (1) two or more government tiers; (2) each tier has its own jurisdiction over the same citizens; (3) jurisdictions are specified in the constitution, constitutionally guaranteeing each tier's existence/authority; (4) fundamental provisions cannot be changed unilaterally by one level — needs both levels' consent; (5) courts (as umpire) interpret the constitution and resolve disputes between levels; (6) each level's revenue sources are clearly specified for financial autonomy; (7) the system has dual objectives — safeguarding national unity while accommodating regional diversity — requiring mutual trust and agreement to live together.
What makes India a federal country?
- The Constitution declares India a 'Union of States' — it never uses the word 'federation', but the Union is based on federalist principles, satisfying all seven features above. It originally set up a two-tier system (Union/Central Government + State Governments); a third tier (Panchayats and Municipalities) was added later.
- Three-fold distribution of legislative powers: Union List (national-importance subjects needing uniform policy — defence, foreign affairs, banking, communications, currency — only Union Government legislates); State List (state/local-importance subjects — police, trade, commerce, agriculture, irrigation — only State Governments legislate); Concurrent List (subjects of common interest — education, forest, trade unions, marriage, adoption, succession — both can legislate, Union law prevails if they conflict). Subjects outside all three lists (residuary subjects, e.g. computer software) fall to the Union Government.
- Not all states have identical powers — Assam, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh and Mizoram enjoy special powers under Article 371 due to peculiar social/historical circumstances (protecting indigenous land rights, culture, preferential government employment; outsiders cannot buy land/houses). Union Territories (Chandigarh, Lakshadweep, Delhi) are areas too small for statehood but not mergeable with existing states — they lack state powers, and the Central Government runs them with special powers.
- This power-sharing is basic to the Constitution's structure and hard to change: any amendment needs at least two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament, then ratification by at least half the state legislatures. The judiciary (High Courts, Supreme Court) oversees implementation and resolves disputes over the division of powers; both Union and State Governments can raise resources through their own taxes.
How is federalism practised?
- Linguistic states — the first major test for Indian democracy. Post-1947, several old state boundaries were redrawn so that people speaking the same language lived together; some states (Nagaland, Uttarakhand, Jharkhand) were created on culture/ethnicity/geography grounds instead. Despite fears this would cause disintegration, linguistic reorganisation actually made the country more united and eased administration.
- Language policy — the second test. No language was given 'national language' status; Hindi was made the official language, though it's the mother tongue of only ~44% of Indians (2011 Census); 21 other languages are recognised as Scheduled Languages (Central exam candidates may use any of them), and states have their own official languages. Unlike Sri Lanka's forced Sinhala-only policy, India was cautious: when English's planned 1965 phase-out sparked violent protest in Tamil Nadu, the Centre agreed English would continue alongside Hindi. Promoting Hindi does not mean imposing it on non-Hindi-speaking states — this flexibility helped India avoid Sri Lanka's fate.
- Centre-State relations — for a long time the same party ruled the Centre and most states, so states didn't exercise their autonomous rights; when a different party ruled a state, the Centre often misused constitutional provisions to dismiss that state government, undermining federalism's spirit. Since 1990, the rise of regional parties and coalition governments at the Centre (no single party getting a Lok Sabha majority, so national parties had to ally with regional ones) brought a new culture of power-sharing and respect for state autonomy, reinforced by a major Supreme Court judgement making arbitrary dismissal of state governments harder.
Decentralisation: the third tier
- India's vast size and internal diversity (Uttar Pradesh's population exceeds Russia's, Maharashtra's is about Germany's) means two tiers aren't enough — power needs sharing within states too, below the state level. Decentralisation means taking power from Central/State governments and giving it to local government, since local problems are often best understood and solved locally, and direct participation builds democratic habits — realising the principle of local self-government.
- Before 1992, panchayats/municipalities existed but were fully state-controlled, elections irregular, with no independent powers/resources — decentralisation was minimal in practice. The 1992 constitutional amendment made the third tier genuinely powerful: regular local-body elections became mandatory; seats reserved for SCs, STs, OBCs (in elected bodies and executive heads); at least one-third of positions reserved for women; independent State Election Commissions set up in each state to conduct these elections; states required to share some powers/revenue with local bodies (varying by state).
- Rural structure (panchayati raj): gram panchayat (village council, ward members/'panch' + president/sarpanch, directly elected, works under gram sabha's supervision — all village voters, meeting 2-3 times a year to approve the budget and review performance) → panchayat samiti/block/mandal (several gram panchayats grouped, members elected by panchayat members) → zilla parishad (all panchayat samitis in a district, mostly elected members plus local MPs/MLAs, headed by a chairperson). Urban structure: municipalities (towns) and municipal corporations (big cities), both elected-body controlled, headed by a chairperson/mayor respectively.
- This is the world's largest democratic experiment at scale — about 36 lakh elected representatives in panchayats/municipalities nationwide, more than the population of many countries; it has deepened democracy and increased women's representation. But challenges remain: gram sabhas aren't held regularly despite enthusiastic elections, and most state governments haven't transferred adequate powers or resources — self-government remains an ideal still being realised. (Porto Alegre, Brazil, and parts of Kerala offer examples of combining decentralisation with genuine participative budget-making.)
Key terms
- Coming together / Holding together federation
- Independent states pooling sovereignty (equal power) vs. a large country devolving power (unequal, centre-heavy).
- Union / State / Concurrent List
- India's three-fold constitutional division of legislative subjects.
- Residuary powers
- Powers over subjects not in any of the three lists, held by the Union Government.
- Decentralisation
- Transferring power from Central/State governments to local government.
- Gram sabha
- The body of all village voters that oversees the gram panchayat.
Quick revision
- 1.7 features of federalism: 2+ tiers, own jurisdiction, constitutionally specified, no unilateral change, judiciary as umpire, own revenue, unity+diversity.
- 2.3 lists: Union (defence, banking) / State (police, agriculture) / Concurrent (education, forests) — Union law prevails on conflict.
- 3.Article 371 special status: Assam, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram.
- 4.Hindi = official language (not national), mother tongue of only ~44%; 22 Scheduled Languages total.
- 5.1992 amendment: mandatory local elections, SC/ST/OBC + 1/3 women reservation, State Election Commissions.
Practice questions
Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.
- 1.What is the difference between a federal and a unitary system of government? Explain with an example.
- 2.How has India's language policy helped avoid the kind of conflict Sri Lanka faced?
- 3.Describe the changes brought about by the 1992 constitutional amendment to strengthen local government in India.
These are original study notes prepared from the NCERT Class X textbook for exam preparation, not a reproduction of it. For the full text, maps and illustrations, read the original textbook on the official NCERT website (ncert.nic.in).