+91 75880 82870
Rajyaseva Setu
← All fundamentals

Indian Polity · Complete Tutorial · Chapter 10

The Judiciary — India's Umpire, Guardian, and Sometimes Lawmaker

Every country with a written constitution needs someone to decide what it actually means when two sides disagree, and the power to strike down a law that crosses the line. In India, that job belongs to a judiciary that is unified and independent in a way few other federations match — and whose method of choosing its own judges has become one of the most debated features in the entire system.

One judiciary, not fifty-one

  • India has a single, integrated judicial system: the Supreme Court at the top, High Courts below it (one or more states can share a High Court, or a state can have its own), and subordinate/district courts below that — all applying the same body of law, with appeals flowing upward through one hierarchy. This is strikingly different from the USA's 'dual' system, where every state runs its own complete court system (state supreme court included) in parallel with a separate federal court system, and the two only intersect at the very top, when the US Supreme Court takes up a case involving federal constitutional questions.
  • Why this matters practically: an Indian citizen's property dispute, criminal trial and constitutional challenge can all potentially travel through the exact same court hierarchy, ending at one Supreme Court — giving India more uniform case law nationwide than the US, where a given legal question can get genuinely different answers in different state court systems until the US Supreme Court (if it ever agrees to hear the issue) settles it.

Judicial review: the power to say 'no' to Parliament

  • Judicial review — the power of courts to declare a law or executive action unconstitutional — isn't spelled out in one single article the way the US Constitution is silent on it too (the US Supreme Court actually invented the power for itself in Marbury v. Madison, 1803, without an explicit textual basis). India's Constitution is more explicit: Articles 13, 32, 131-136, 143, 226 and 246 together clearly establish it, and Kesavananda Bharati (1973) later confirmed judicial review is itself part of the Constitution's unamendable 'basic structure'.
  • Judicial activism — courts going beyond narrowly deciding the case in front of them to actively direct government policy — grew especially through Public Interest Litigations (PILs) from the 1980s onward, where even a letter or newspaper report could trigger Supreme Court action on behalf of people who couldn't otherwise access courts. Famous examples: the Vishaka Guidelines (1997), where the Supreme Court essentially wrote workplace sexual harassment rules into existence because Parliament hadn't legislated on the subject yet (until the POSH Act finally codified it in 2013); and continuing Monitoring of the Ganga/Yamuna pollution cases. Critics call this judicial overreach into the executive's and legislature's domain; supporters call it the Court filling a vacuum when elected branches fail to act.

How judges actually get appointed — the Collegium System

  • The Constitution's text says Supreme Court and High Court judges are appointed by the President 'after consultation with' the Chief Justice of India and other judges (Article 124, 217). Through a series of judgments — the 'Three Judges Cases' (1981, 1993, 1998) — the Supreme Court interpreted 'consultation' to mean the judiciary's recommendation is effectively binding, creating the 'Collegium System': a group of the CJI and the 4 senior-most Supreme Court judges who decide on judicial appointments and transfers, largely outside the executive's control.
  • In 2014-15, Parliament tried to replace this with the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) — a body including the executive and 'eminent persons' alongside judges, via the 99th Amendment. In 2015, the Supreme Court struck the NJAC down as unconstitutional, holding that it threatened judicial independence (part of the basic structure), restoring the Collegium System. Comparison with the USA: American federal judges, including Supreme Court Justices, are nominated by the President and must be confirmed by the Senate — an explicitly political, public process. India's Collegium is the opposite extreme: judges effectively choosing judges, with almost no elected-branch role at all — a genuinely unusual arrangement found in very few other democracies, and still an active, unresolved debate in Indian polity.

Key terms

Judicial review
Courts' power to strike down unconstitutional laws/actions — part of the basic structure since Kesavananda Bharati.
Collegium System
CJI + 4 senior-most SC judges who decide judicial appointments/transfers, created through judicial interpretation, not the Constitution's text.
PIL (Public Interest Litigation)
A case brought on behalf of the public good, often by someone other than the directly affected party, expanding court access.

Quick revision

  • 1.India has ONE integrated judiciary (SC → HCs → subordinate courts); the USA has a DUAL system (separate state + federal court hierarchies).
  • 2.Judicial review: explicit in India (Arts. 13, 32, 226, 246…); the US Supreme Court invented it for itself in Marbury v. Madison (1803).
  • 3.Collegium System (from the Three Judges Cases, 1981/93/98): CJI + 4 senior SC judges decide appointments, largely outside executive control.
  • 4.NJAC (99th Amendment, 2014) struck down in 2015 as unconstitutional — judicial independence is part of the basic structure.

Practice questions

Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.

  1. 1.How does India's integrated judicial system differ from the USA's dual court system, and what practical difference does this make for case law?
  2. 2.Trace how the Collegium System came into being, and why the Supreme Court struck down the NJAC in 2015.
  3. 3.Using the Vishaka Guidelines as an example, explain what 'judicial activism' means and why it is controversial.

These are original explainer notes written for MPSC exam preparation — not sourced from or affiliated with any single textbook. For the exact constitutional text, refer to the Constitution of India on india.gov.in or legislative.gov.in.