Indian Polity · Complete Tutorial · Chapter 11
The Governor — A Mini-President With a Few Extra, Controversial Powers
A Governor's job looks, at first glance, like a smaller copy of the President's — act on the aid and advice of the state Council of Ministers, headed by the Chief Minister. But Governors are appointed, not elected, by the Centre, and hold a handful of discretionary powers that have made them the single most politically controversial office in India's federal system — Maharashtra has supplied some of the most-cited examples in the country.
Appointed by the Centre, answerable mostly to convention
- Article 155 says the Governor is appointed by the President — in practice, chosen by the Union government — and holds office 'during the pleasure of the President' (Article 156), meaning they can be removed essentially at will, with no fixed term genuinely protected. This is structurally very different from an elected Chief Minister, and it's exactly why critics describe Governors as instruments through which the Centre can influence, or interfere with, state governments run by a rival party.
- Normally, the Governor acts on the advice of the state Council of Ministers, just like the President does at the Centre. But Governors retain real discretion in a few specific situations: deciding who to invite to form a government after a hung Assembly election, deciding how much time to give a newly sworn-in CM to prove majority on the floor, deciding whether to reserve a state bill for the President's consideration, and recommending President's Rule (Article 356) based on their own assessment that a state's government cannot function per the Constitution.
Maharashtra's own case studies in Governor's discretion
- November 2019: after a hung Maharashtra Assembly election, Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari administered a pre-dawn oath of office to Devendra Fadnavis as Chief Minister and Ajit Pawar as Deputy Chief Minister in a surprise early-morning ceremony — a government that collapsed within 80 hours when Ajit Pawar's claimed NCP support turned out not to hold. The Supreme Court, in a fast-tracked hearing, ordered an immediate floor test, forcing the issue to be settled on the Assembly floor rather than allowed to drag out — a widely studied example of how quickly a Governor's discretionary call can be tested, and overturned in effect, by judicial intervention.
- Earlier, in June 2022, a split within the Shiv Sena (Eknath Shinde's faction breaking away) led to a floor test being ordered, and Uddhav Thackeray resigned as CM without facing it — triggering a separate, long-running Supreme Court case about the Speaker's and Governor's roles during a party split, and about whether the Governor was right to order a floor test at all at that specific moment. Together, these two episodes are frequently used in MPSC mains answers to illustrate the gap between how the Governor's office is written on paper versus how contested it can become in practice — essential, lived context for a Maharashtra-focused exam.
Chief Minister and the state Council of Ministers
- The structure mirrors the Centre almost exactly: the Governor appoints the CM (whoever can command an Assembly majority), and other ministers on the CM's advice (Article 164); collective responsibility to the Legislative Assembly applies the same way it does to the Lok Sabha at the Centre. The real practical difference across states isn't constitutional at all — it's political: how strong the CM's own party position is, how the state's legislative council (where one exists, like Maharashtra's) is composed, and how often that particular state has experienced central interference through the Governor's office or Article 356.
Key terms
- Governor's discretion
- Narrow situations (hung Assembly, bill reservation, Art. 356 recommendation) where Governors can act without ministerial advice.
- Floor test
- A vote on the Assembly floor to confirm whether a CM/government actually commands majority support.
- 'Pleasure of the President' (Art. 156)
- A Governor can be removed at any time by the Union government, with no fixed protected term.
Quick revision
- 1.Governor appointed by President (really, the Centre) under Art. 155; holds office 'during the President's pleasure' (Art. 156) — no fixed secure term.
- 2.Real discretion: inviting CM in hung Assembly, time to prove majority, reserving bills for President, recommending President's Rule.
- 3.Nov 2019 Maharashtra: pre-dawn oath (Fadnavis-Ajit Pawar) collapsed in 80 hrs after SC ordered immediate floor test.
- 4.June 2022 Maharashtra: Shiv Sena split (Shinde faction) → floor test ordered → Thackeray resigned without facing it → ongoing SC case on Governor/Speaker's role.
Practice questions
Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.
- 1.What specific discretionary powers does a Governor retain despite normally acting on ministerial advice? Illustrate with the 2019 Maharashtra episode.
- 2.Why is the Governor's office often described as a tool for central interference in state governments? What structural feature causes this?
These are original explainer notes written for MPSC exam preparation — not sourced from or affiliated with any single textbook. For the exact constitutional text, refer to the Constitution of India on india.gov.in or legislative.gov.in.