Ethics, Integrity & Aptitude · Complete Tutorial · Chapter 1
What Is Ethics, and Why Does a Civil Servant Need It?
Laws tell you what you must do, or risk punishment. Ethics is the quieter, harder question underneath that: what SHOULD you do, even when no one is watching and no rule technically forces your hand? A civil servant spends most of their career exactly there — in the gap between what's legally permitted and what's actually right — which is why 'ethics' isn't a soft, optional topic for an administrator, it's the daily job.
Three ways to ask 'is this right?'
- Philosophers have long split ethical reasoning into three broad families, and almost every real dilemma you'll face mixes all three. Consequentialism (most famously utilitarianism, from Bentham and Mill) judges an action by its outcomes — the right choice is whichever produces the greatest good for the greatest number. Deontology (from Kant) judges an action by whether it follows a universal duty or rule, regardless of outcome — some things (lying, breaking a promise) are wrong even if they'd produce a good result this one time. Virtue ethics (from Aristotle) asks a different question entirely: not 'what should I do' but 'what would a genuinely honest, courageous, temperate person do here' — character first, rules and outcomes second.
- Why this matters practically: these three lenses genuinely disagree sometimes. A utilitarian officer might divert scarce flood-relief funds from a small, loud village to a larger, quieter one because it helps more people — a deontologist might object that promises already made to the small village create a binding duty regardless of the larger village's size. Recognising which lens you (or your senior, or the public) are implicitly using in any disagreement is often the fastest way to actually understand what the argument is really about.
Determinants of ethics: what actually shapes a person's choices
- No one makes ethical choices in a vacuum — several forces shape them: family upbringing and early role models; religion and cultural tradition; the law and institutional rules a person operates under; peer pressure and organisational culture (an honest officer posted into a deeply corrupt department faces constant pressure to conform); and individual conscience, built up through reflection and experience. In administration, organisational culture is often the most underrated determinant — plenty of individually well-intentioned officers still end up participating in corrupt systems simply because 'that's how it's done here' becomes the path of least resistance.
Consequences of ethics (and its absence) in human actions
- When ethics holds, institutions earn trust, and trust is what makes governance actually efficient — people comply with rules voluntarily, cooperate with officials, and don't need every transaction policed. When it fails, the costs are concrete and often fatal, not abstract. The 2017 Kamala Mills fire in Mumbai, which killed 14 people, followed years of fire-safety and licensing violations that local authorities had reportedly overlooked — a stark, local example of how an unethical compromise ('look the other way for a small favour') can scale up into real loss of life, not just a technical violation on paper.
- Globally, the Volkswagen 'Dieselgate' scandal (2015) — where the company installed software specifically to cheat emissions tests across millions of vehicles — shows the same pattern at corporate scale: a culture that normalised cutting ethical corners for commercial targets eventually cost the company over $30 billion in fines and settlements and, more lastingly, destroyed public trust that took years to even partially rebuild. The lesson repeated across both examples: ethical failure is rarely one person's one bad decision — it's usually a system that made the bad decision feel normal.
Key terms
- Consequentialism / Utilitarianism
- Judges an action by its outcomes — the greatest good for the greatest number (Bentham, Mill).
- Deontology
- Judges an action by whether it follows a universal duty, regardless of outcome (Kant).
- Virtue ethics
- Asks what a person of good character would do, rather than applying a rule or calculating outcomes (Aristotle).
Quick revision
- 1.3 lenses: consequentialism (outcomes), deontology (duty/rules), virtue ethics (character) — real dilemmas usually mix all three.
- 2.Determinants of ethical choice: upbringing, religion/culture, law, organisational culture (often most underrated), individual conscience.
- 3.2017 Kamala Mills fire (14 dead) & 2015 VW Dieselgate ($30bn+ cost): both show ethical failure as a systemic, not individual, pattern.
Practice questions
Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.
- 1.A utilitarian and a deontologist look at the same flood-relief funding decision and disagree. Explain why, using the two frameworks.
- 2.Using the Kamala Mills fire as an example, explain how organisational culture can be a stronger determinant of unethical behaviour than any one individual's intentions.
These are original explainer notes written for MPSC exam preparation, covering the standard Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude syllabus — not sourced from or affiliated with any single textbook. They are a study aid, not professional ethical or legal guidance.