+91 75880 82870
Rajyaseva Setu
← All fundamentals

Ethics, Integrity & Aptitude · Complete Tutorial · Chapter 7

Accountability — Making Sure Power Always Has to Answer to Someone

Power without accountability tends to drift toward abuse, not because every official is secretly corrupt, but because the absence of a check removes the one thing that reliably keeps anyone honest over time: knowing you might have to explain yourself. India builds accountability through overlapping mechanisms — some built into the Constitution, some added later by ordinary legislation — and the Right to Information Act is the one that most directly puts power into an ordinary citizen's hands.

Vertical and horizontal accountability

  • Vertical accountability runs between citizens and the state — elections, a free press, and public protest are the main tools, letting citizens reward or punish those in power periodically. Horizontal accountability runs between different arms of the state itself — the judiciary reviewing executive action, the CAG auditing government spending, the Lokpal/Lokayukta investigating corruption complaints, and legislative committees scrutinising ministries. A healthy democracy needs both working simultaneously: vertical accountability alone only fires once every few years at election time, which is far too slow to catch most day-to-day abuses of power — horizontal mechanisms exist precisely to fill that gap in real time.

RTI — the law that turned 'secret' government files into a citizen's right

  • The Right to Information Act, 2005 flipped the colonial-era default (the Official Secrets Act, 1923, which presumed government information was secret unless specifically released) into its opposite: citizens have a right to demand information, and the state must justify withholding it, not the other way around. It followed sustained grassroots pressure, most famously from the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan's (MKSS) 1990s campaigns in rural Rajasthan, where villagers used public hearings ('jan sunwais') to compare official spending records against what was actually built on the ground, exposing ghost workers and phantom construction projects — demonstrating transparency's practical power well before it became national law.
  • A Maharashtra-relevant, high-profile RTI success: the Adarsh Housing Society scam in Mumbai came to wide public attention largely through RTI applications and activist/journalist scrutiny revealing that a building meant for Kargil war widows and veterans had instead been allotted mostly to politicians, bureaucrats and their relatives, violating multiple coastal and height-regulation norms — leading to a judicial commission of inquiry and, eventually, demolition orders. The episode is a clean, local illustration of horizontal accountability (courts, commissions) and vertical/citizen-driven accountability (RTI, media, public outrage) reinforcing each other rather than working in isolation.

Key terms

Vertical accountability
Citizens holding the state accountable, mainly through elections, press and protest.
Horizontal accountability
One arm of the state checking another — courts, CAG, Lokpal, legislative committees.
RTI Act, 2005
Reversed the default: citizens now have a right to information, and the state must justify withholding it.

Quick revision

  • 1.Vertical accountability (citizens → state, via elections/press) + horizontal accountability (state arm → state arm, via courts/CAG/Lokpal) — need both.
  • 2.RTI Act 2005 reversed the Official Secrets Act 1923 default; grew out of MKSS's 1990s Rajasthan jan sunwai campaigns.
  • 3.Adarsh Housing Society scam (Mumbai): RTI + media exposure → judicial commission → demolition orders — vertical & horizontal accountability reinforcing each other.

Practice questions

Try writing your own answer first, then compare with the notes above.

  1. 1.Why does a healthy democracy need both vertical and horizontal accountability mechanisms, rather than relying on elections alone?
  2. 2.Using the Adarsh Housing Society scam, explain how RTI and judicial/institutional mechanisms worked together to expose and address wrongdoing.

These are original explainer notes written for MPSC exam preparation, covering the standard Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude syllabus — not sourced from or affiliated with any single textbook. They are a study aid, not professional ethical or legal guidance.